Saturdays X Factor (10Nov07), left all four judges with at least one of their acts gone, with Andy, Dannii’s act getting the axe.The show was packed with its fair share of great performances and the not-so great performances, and it seemed Andy was one of the not-so great acts, when he sung, ‘Chasing cars’, which it seemed wasn’t the best song choice. Andy was out of tune from the start of his performance, but his X Factor rivals were really shocked and upset to see him in the bottom two with Beverley, who sung, ‘you’re beautiful’.Louis had to decide first for who he wanted to send home. Of course he backed his own act, Beverley and chose that he wanted to get rid of Andy. Next it was Sharon who also chose that Beverley would potentially do better than Andy and so she chose Beverley to stay and Andy to go. Andy was tearful by the time it come for Dannii who obviously chose Andy to stay. To make the final decision it was up to Simon who said Beverley gave a hotel performance and both of them in his mind, were given the wrong song. So based on who thought the public would most like to see stay Simon saved Beverley, ending Andy’s dream.Andy was upset and described what he had been feeling like a dream but when he was evicted a dream gone bad. Dannii felt guilty for her acts exit but he didn’t blame her for getting voted off.