Wow! How Louis could say this girl wasn't good enough to get through to the bootcamp stages of X Factor but put someone like Shirlena Johnson through is beyond me, I thought she was fantastic!
Granted she looked a little bit too much like Madonna and has been accused of already having broken the shows rules after being linked to Simon Cowell and Sony BMG.
You see, the 24-year-old from Hertfordshire is also known as Lola Fontaine, singer of a jazz album and owner of a record deal in the US as well as Katie Vogel, star of a reality TV show, sponsored by Coca Cola and watchable online.
So, whilst she nailed her version of Etta James' 'At Last' and 'fluffed' her lines to Queens 'We Are The Champions', there are rumbles that it could all be a set up by Simon and friends to boost Katie's publicity.
If it's true that Katie has broken the rules regarding the show I am going to be super angry, but if not, she's my favourite so far, God knows I'd kill to have a voice like hers - she is undoubtedly the Diana Vickers of this years show.
FemaleFirst - Ruth Harrison
Tagged in The X Factor